MedAI Verdict

AI Medical Scribe

Editorial illustration: a stethoscope alongside a clinical encounter audio waveform feeding into a structured chart note.

CarePilot vs MedScrub

All comparisons
42/ 100

CarePilot

Competitive
36/ 100

MedScrub

Competitive

Around the visit, on the chart, is where MedScrub operates. Its pages describe overnight summaries, trended labs, flagged open plans, pre-visit prep and chart chat, run on the clinician's own machine, and the vendor states it strips the 18 HIPAA Safe Harbor identifiers before a model sees the data. CarePilot works inside the visit, filling SOAP fields live and putting suggested CPT codes and drafted orders into athenaOne.

A 6-provider practice that wants open plans from prior visits checked buys MedScrub. Its Practice tier is $89 per provider per month billed annually and Solo is $99 per month, currency not stated, and 501(c)(3) healthcare nonprofits with a determination letter get a free tier. A practice that wants the encounter documented live buys CarePilot, quoted per provider monthly.

No buyer sets the two side by side, since MedScrub's pages describe chart summarization and pre-visit prep, not visit documentation.

AI medical scribes · Reviewed November 2, 2026

On this page
CarePilot logo

CarePilot

by DocuCare Inc. · founded 2023

AI notes, ICD-10 and CPT coding, and orders drafted inside athenaOne, for independent athenahealth practices.

MedScrub logo

MedScrub

by 1PuttHealth

Chart summarization and pre-visit prep that runs on a local machine and strips HIPAA identifiers before any model sees the data.

When to pick each one

CarePilot

  • Live SOAP fields and CPT suggestions in the visit
  • Orders drafted into the athenaOne queue
Read the full CarePilot review

MedScrub

  • $89 per provider monthly, billed annually, currency not stated
  • Overnight chart summaries and pre-visit prep
  • Free tier for 501(c)(3) healthcare nonprofits
Read the full MedScrub review

Score

Each row shows points earned of points available under the published rubric.

CarePilot

42of 100Competitive

MedScrub

36of 100Competitive
Score by dimension for CarePilot and MedScrub
DimensionCarePilotMedScrubDifference
HIPAA / SOC2 / BAA13 / 130 / 13+13
EHR integrations (count)6.3 / 2110.5 / 21-4.2
Top-3 EHR coverage (Epic / Oracle / Athena)4.8 / 1212 / 12-7.2
Bidirectional write-back0 / 5.20 / 5.20
Peer-reviewed papers2.8 / 70 / 7+2.8
RCT / meta-analysis / systematic review0 / 30 / 30
Funding & adoption signal3 / 123 / 120
Pricing transparency2.5 / 55 / 5-2.5
Years in market3 / 60 / 6+3

Scroll horizontally to see every column.

How scores are computed

Pricing

CarePilot

TierMonthlyAnnualNotes
EnterpriseNot statedNot statedNo public price.

Verified November 2, 2026 from carepilot.com (opens in new tab).

MedScrub

TierMonthlyAnnualNotes
HobbyNot statedNot statedFor developers: 500 credits at sign-up. The page does not label its currency; USD is assumed from the "$" signs.
Solo$99Not statedAnnual billing available; the page says it saves $600 a year. Currency not labeled; USD assumed.
Practice$89Not statedFor 2 to 10 providers. Save $480 a year versus monthly. Example: two providers at $178 a month. Currency not labeled; USD assumed.
Credits 3,000Not statedNot statedDeveloper credit bundle of 3,000 credits. Credits never expire. Currency not labeled; USD assumed.
Credits 10,000Not statedNot statedDeveloper credit bundle of 10,000 credits. Credits never expire. Currency not labeled; USD assumed.
Credits 100,000Not statedNot statedDeveloper credit bundle of 100,000 credits. Credits never expire. Currency not labeled; USD assumed.
NonprofitNot statedNot statedFree for 501(c)(3) healthcare nonprofits with a determination letter.
EnterpriseNot statedNot statedNo public price. Custom pricing.

Evidence

MedScrub

No FDA decision, peer-reviewed study or community post in our record.

Compliance and integrations

Documented from each vendor’s own pages.

SpecCarePilotMedScrub
Free tierNo / unverifiedYes
HIPAAYesNo / unverified
SOC 2 Type IIYesNo / unverified
EHR integrationsathenahealthEpic, Oracle Health, athenahealth, eClinicalWorks
Founded2023Not stated
HQUSNot stated

Scroll horizontally to see both columns.

Common questions

Open the full AI medical scribes comparison

The best AI medical scribe for most US physicians is Abridge for hospital systems, Freed AI for solo practice (plans from $39 to $119 per month as of October 2026), Heidi Health for multilingual capture, and DAX Copilot for Microsoft-shop hospitals. Each pick below names its primary EHR integration, pricing model, and the clinician communities that surface it most often. Enterprise scribes are quote-based, with third-party estimates of roughly $208 to $600 per provider per month as of October 2026.

See all AI medical scribes